Fireside Chats’ series from the 2024 Cedigaz Seminar

Didier Holleaux, EVP at Engie and President at Eurogas, author of « La vraie histoire du gaz ».

Didier Holleaux addressing the audiance at the Cedigaz sseminar 2024
Didier Holleaux addressing the audience at the Cedigaz seminar 2024

At the 2023 seminar, there were a lot of concerns regarding the capacity of European gas companies to sign new long-term contracts to secure additional supplies in the wake of the energy crisis. Such concerns seem to have eased this year. Has this changed?

After the crisis, some companies have taken different strategies. Some of them secured a very large share of new long-term deals and still want to rely on long-term contracts. Others in Europe, particularly the ones that burnt their fingers in this crisis, are far more reluctant to sign new long-term contracts because they have been under pressure from their shareholders to avoid being dependent on new long-term deals which made their life difficult in the wake of the war. Therefore, they will tend to rely far more on spot markets, even if they know that in times of severe crisis, they may face difficulties.Quote

We do see more diverging strategies amongst companies, and that’s perhaps one of the lessons drawn from the past year. This very much depends on the kind of risk that companies’ shareholders are prepared to accept.

Another key factor depends on the location of your customers and where you are based as a supplier. Clearly, if you are close to a node of the network, you can import from very different places and diversify your supply under your long-term contract. In other places, you may have difficulties in finding a diversity of sellers willing to propose long-term contracts.

VIEWS FROM THE CEDIGAZ 2024 SEMINAR

SHIFTING THE FOCUS ON GAS DEMAND, HARD TRUTHS AND BOLDER ADVOCACY

Pragmatism, optionality and communication were the words of the day at Cedigaz’ traditional annual seminar held in Paris on June 20th. Members of the European gas industry and overseas producers say these are badly needed to make long-term plans, ensure energy security and a ‘just’ energy transition. More than two years after the unprecedented energy crisis sparked by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, the list of challenges is not short: worsening global macro-economics, industrial demand destruction, chaotic global geopolitics, the imperative to fight climate change, and the necessity for Europe to boost its economic competitiveness and stem the tide of populism that has been fueled by higher food, energy and costs of living.

Political Uncertainty

The event, which brought together more than 70 delegates active across the gas value chain, was dominated by bittersweet feelings. The fact that Europe managed to avert major energy blackouts and worst-case scenarios after the war in Ukraine broke out demonstrated its capacity to respond to reduced Russian gas pipeline supplies.

But this was not without record prices spikes and wider socio-economic damages, from job losses at industrial sites in Europe, to costs incurred by poorer nations in emerging markets who could not afford to pay record LNG prices and turned to coal and oil for their own energy security.

Global demand for natural gas only marginally recovered from the shock caused by the cut in Russian natural gas supply a year earlier

After a 1.5% decline in 2022, marked by the gas supply crisis caused by the Russia-Ukraine war, global natural gas consumption recovered slightly in 2023, with an estimated growth rate of 0.6%. The Russian gas crisis has led to tense market conditions as global LNG supply growth was too limited to compensate for the cut of Russian gas supplies to Europe. However, a number of economic, technological and weather factors eased the market and tempered the pressure on both demand and prices in 2023.  Europe stands out with a very steep decline in demand to its lowest level since 1995. Driven by this steep reduction in natural gas demand and record-high gas storage levels, European gas prices fell considerably while remaining highly volatile. Asian spot LNG prices followed a similar trajectory. The global market experienced a gradual rebalancing throughout 2023 and natural gas storages closed the year at or near the top of the five-year range in all three key regions (North America, Europe and Northeast Asia).